
Grid-forming and grid-following describe how an inverter-based resource establishes or follows voltage angle, frequency and terminal voltage. A grid-following BESS normally synchronizes to an existing electrical reference and controls active and reactive current or power. A grid-forming BESS uses an internal reference and controls voltage and frequency behaviour, subject to its energy, current and control limits. Neither label is a complete procurement specification.
For a strong utility connection used mainly for peak shaving, solar self-consumption or tariff dispatch, grid-following control may satisfy the project. A weak grid, island system, black-start requirement or inverter-dominated microgrid may require grid-forming behaviour, but only after the network study defines the necessary functions. Buyers reviewing a commercial and industrial BESS should specify operating states and performance tests instead of asking only whether the PCS “supports GFM.”
Procurement rule: choose control behaviour from the system study, then contract the voltage, frequency, current-limit, transition, protection and model-validation performance needed at the point of connection.
Research review date: 17 November 2026. Requirements differ by grid operator, voltage level, market and project configuration. This article does not claim that every HMX PCS or BESS configuration provides grid-forming functions; availability and test evidence must be confirmed for the selected equipment and destination.
Start with the Electrical Reference the Site Will Actually Have
A connected factory usually receives a stable voltage and frequency reference from the utility network. During a planned or unplanned island, that reference may disappear. An islanded system then needs at least one source capable of establishing the AC waveform and balancing real-time changes in generation and load. That source may be a synchronous generator, a grid-forming PCS or a coordinated combination. The design also needs enough stored energy and power headroom to sustain the response.
The Asian Development Bank’s technical guide distinguishes grid-following control, where voltage and frequency are set by the grid, from grid-forming modes that act on voltage and frequency error. It also separates droop and isochronous approaches, which is one reason a buyer should not treat every grid-forming implementation as identical. Read ADB’s Hybrid and Battery Energy Storage Systems guide for the control-mode context.
| Procurement dimension | Grid-following emphasis | Grid-forming emphasis |
|---|---|---|
| Electrical reference | Tracks an existing grid voltage and frequency | Establishes an internal voltage/frequency reference |
| Typical control objective | Active/reactive current or power setpoints | Voltage/frequency behaviour and power sharing |
| Strong-grid use | Common for grid-connected energy services | May be unnecessary unless a specified service requires it |
| Weak-grid or island use | Requires study of PLL and network interactions | Can support the reference, but still requires tuning and study |
| Black start | Cannot be inferred from ordinary grid-following operation | Possible only with defined energisation sequence and auxiliary supply |
| Fault response | Current-limited response must be modeled | Also current-limited; not equivalent to synchronous-machine fault current |
| Evidence | Validated RMS/EMT models, ride-through and setpoint tests | Additional GFM functions, current-limit behaviour and island tests |
Control responsibilities extend beyond the PCS. The BMS protects the battery, the PCS executes fast electrical control, and the EMS or microgrid controller coordinates dispatch and operating states. The HMX guide to BMS, PCS and EMS control-loop ownership helps separate these layers before a supplier meeting.

Use a Scenario Test Before Naming the Control Mode
The buyer’s first study should be a state diagram. List every combination that matters: utility connected, generator running, PV available, BESS charging, BESS discharging, transition to island, black start, load rejection, fault, depleted battery and return to grid. Identify the voltage/frequency reference, active-power balancer, reactive-power controller and protection philosophy for each state.
| Site condition or duty | Question to resolve | Likely study output |
|---|---|---|
| Strong grid, no islanding | Are energy dispatch and reactive-power functions the complete duty? | Grid-following may be adequate, subject to grid code and study |
| Weak point of connection | What are system strength, impedance and nearby inverter interactions? | RMS and possibly EMT study with validated models |
| Planned island | Which source establishes voltage and frequency after separation? | Control hierarchy, load balance and transition sequence |
| Black start | How are auxiliaries powered, the bus energised and loads stepped? | Cold-start sequence, load-step limits and protection checks |
| Diesel plus BESS | Which device leads, and how is power shared without hunting? | Droop, minimum generator loading and transition settings |
| High inverter share | Can controls remain stable across credible network configurations? | Model-based tuning and interaction tests |
| Critical motor load | Can voltage and current limits support the start sequence? | Dynamic load model and staged-start plan |
NERC’s 2025 BESS and hybrid performance-modeling guideline describes grid-forming operation in terms of reliable operation with few or no synchronous machines and identifies enabling conditions such as an energy buffer, voltage/frequency regulation, low control latency and a robust DC voltage. Although the guideline addresses bulk-power reliability, the procurement lesson carries into smaller systems: control functions depend on energy availability, hierarchy and models, not on a single checkbox.
Do not merge black start, backup and grid forming
These terms overlap but are not synonyms. Grid-forming control concerns electrical reference behaviour. Black start concerns energising a dead system without relying on the external grid. Backup concerns serving selected loads when the normal source is unavailable. A project may need one, two or all three. The article Black Start Is Not Backup sets out the additional sequence, auxiliary-power and load-restoration questions that belong in the specification.
Specify Performance at Current Limit and During Transitions
Inverter current is limited. When voltage falls or a large load step occurs, the controller must decide how to allocate current among active power, reactive support and protection objectives. The requested grid-forming response must therefore include current-limit behaviour, priority logic and recovery after the limit clears. A claim of virtual inertia or fault support without duration, headroom and current limits is not testable. The project should also connect that headroom to its BESS capacity augmentation plan so the required response is not assumed to remain unchanged as available energy declines.
Protection must be reviewed at the same time. NERC’s functional specification for grid-forming BESS includes disturbance ride-through, fault-current and negative-sequence contribution among the performance areas that require definition, while stating that grid-forming characteristics remain within equipment rating limits. For a C&I or microgrid project, the study should check relay pickup, directionality, transformer energisation, grounding, fault clearing, island boundaries and reclose logic with the actual PCS current response.
Transitions also deserve named tests. A system can operate acceptably in steady grid-connected and steady island modes yet fail during separation or resynchronisation. Define acceptable voltage and frequency excursions, transfer sequence, load shedding, generator coordination and conditions for return. The return path needs controlled synchronism criteria, authority, timeouts and a defined response to failed closing attempts.
Demand Models and Test Records That Match the Delivered Firmware
A weak-grid or GFM study is only as useful as the model and parameters. The purchaser should request the model type required by the network study, parameter version, validity range, known limitations and process for updating it after a firmware or hardware change. RMS models may support many planning studies; fast control interactions can require electromagnetic transient analysis. The responsible engineer or grid authority should decide the required tools and cases.
System context remains important even when the control function is clearly named. The Asian Development Bank’s Handbook on Battery Energy Storage System treats storage across grid applications and microgrids rather than as an isolated battery product. The procurement implication is practical: connect each requested control function to the site architecture, service and operating state, then obtain the destination-specific interconnection requirements from the responsible authority.

| Release gate | Evidence requested | Failure the evidence addresses |
|---|---|---|
| Design freeze | State diagram, control narrative, single-line, load list and study cases | Unowned or contradictory control states |
| Model acceptance | Validated model, parameters, firmware mapping and benchmark cases | Study does not represent delivered controls |
| Factory testing | Mode changes, setpoint response, current limit, alarms and fallback states | Feature exists in a menu but not in an integrated sequence |
| Site energisation | Phasing, protection, metering, communication and interlock checks | Field wiring or settings invalidate the study |
| Island/weak-grid test | Approved load steps, voltage/frequency traces and controller logs | Instability or limit behaviour is not captured |
| Reconnection | Synchronism criteria, authority, timeout and failed-attempt response | Unsafe or repeated closing attempts |
| Handover | Settings backup, model package, firmware record, training and retest triggers | Later changes destroy the validated baseline |
Questions to Put in the RFQ
- Which exact operating modes and firmware versions are offered for the selected PCS?
- What voltage, frequency, droop, inertia-like or damping functions are configurable?
- What energy and active/reactive current headroom is required for each response?
- How does the controller behave at current limit, low SOC and loss of communication?
- Which device is the reference in every grid, island, generator and black-start state?
- Which validated RMS and EMT models are available, under what access conditions?
- Which FAT and SAT cases demonstrate the contracted functions?
- What changes require a model update, settings review or regression test?
The RFQ should include the destination grid code, point-of-connection data, transformer and feeder information, credible system configurations, load dynamics, generator data and operating sequence. Project references can help establish scope, but buyers should ask for configuration-specific evidence rather than assuming that one project demonstrates another control duty.
Frequently Asked Questions
Does every BESS need grid-forming control?
No. A strong-grid, non-islanding project may achieve its required energy and reactive-power services with grid-following control. The network study and operating states should establish the need.
Can grid-forming firmware make any PCS suitable for a weak grid?
No. Hardware current limits, DC energy, thermal capacity, control implementation, protection, plant coordination and validated models all matter. Confirm the exact equipment and firmware combination.
Is a grid-forming BESS automatically a UPS?
No. Load transfer time, continuity class, fault clearing, neutral and earthing arrangement, bypass design and critical-load requirements still need separate engineering and testing.
What should a buyer send for an initial review?
Provide the single-line diagram, point-of-connection data, utility requirements, transformer and generator details, load list, islanding and black-start expectations, PV/inverter data and required operating states. Use the HMX project enquiry page to start a configuration discussion; final capability must be confirmed in project documents and tests.